TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
Climate Change
The home of latest and greatest in climate change and youth action news! Post here on stories from your backyard and around the world. Share successes, reflections, ideas...

Featuring a feed from It's Getting Hot in Here, the blog of the global youth climate movement, THIS is the place to be!

Join up and speak out!



« previous 5


cydnairobi   cydnairobi P.J. Partington's TIGblog
P.J. Partington's profile

Wrap-up from the UN General Assembly debate on Climate Change

"For Papua New Guinea, and I suspect many other countries, the time for mind-numbing debate has passed. The time for leadership has arrived! We cannot idly watch our island communities slip silently under the waves of sea level rise, our villages torn apart by cyclones of increasing fury or our children die of new virulent diseases."

- Robert Aisi, Ambassador to UN, Papua New Guinea


Firstly, apologies for the delay and brevity in this post; my original one was accidentally deleted when it was almost done and it took me over a day to recover from my crankiness and try again!

The climate change thematic ‘debate’ has now wrapped up at the UN General Assembly in New York. I put the word debate in quotations because the relation between the reading of 117 pre-scripted statements and actual constructive debate is somewhat tenuous. Lack of spontaneity aside, there were some heartening elements alongside the disheartening ones.

Firstly, it was great to see the number of countries that wanted to speak on the issue. It shows that the UN has certainly touched on something the global community feels it has a key role in addressing, and rightly so. The G.A. debate was scheduled for the 12th, but went several days over time. 117 statements at 5 minutes each (most of them actually going much longer) doesn’t fit well into a six-hour day! As our observer badges (and travel plans) covered only the 11-12th, our two youth representatives could only be there for the first day of speeches.

Most countries – many of which were represented by ministers (over 20!) or special emissaries, lead negotiators, etc on climate change – spoke on the need to maintain momentum in the difficult process leading to Copenhagen and of the centrality of the UN to the process. Talk of the Bali Action Plan was ubiquitous, and many countries were keen to continue pushing the process forward. The other main theme was the importance of integrating climate change and sustainable development.

Here are a few of the key highlights from the statements given on the 12th:

Many countries in the Small Island Developing State (SIDS), Least Developed Country (LDC), and African groups spoke of the connection between climate change and their progress towards achieving the Millennium Development Goals. Ministers emphasised that for low-lying islands and arid states, climate change is an existential issue (in other words, climate change impacts such as sea-level rise or drought are threatening their very existence). For many, adaptation is not a choice; it is already necessary and without assistance from the international community, funds are being diverted from other pressing development needs. There is an urgent need for more assistance and support, which many hope will be a major part of the new agreement forged in Copenhagen.

Both the US and China expressed their support for the Bali Action Plan, daring one to be hopeful that greatness can be achieved by 2009. Mozambique summed up the urgency for success in these negotiations: “If we lose this opportunity we cannot win this battle.”

The minister from France proposed a set of three principles to guide this plan towards Copenhagen: Responsibility, Equity, and Pragmatism. Tackling climate change will require a “new paradigm of collective security and development.”

One of the best was the Philippines’, which was rich with clear proposals and examples of success. They also spoke of the importance of civil society and activism, praising NGOs for their “persistence and passion,” their “ubiquitous connections to grassroots stakeholders” and their role in keeping governments accountable. Call me biased (I am!), but I thought that was well deserved. It’s not often ordinary dedicated citizens get credit for the important role they play in these processes.

From a more critical angle, despite many interesting interventions the day was also largely full of countries talking about (and mostly to) themselves. For a debate that was supposed to be about how the UN can be most effective in responding to climate change and “delivering as one” by co-ordinating the climate work of its many bodies and agencies, there were surprisingly few suggestions. Furthermore, the pre-scripted statement format barred any opportunity to discuss the items that actually were proposed.

(I’ll put this in brackets to emphasise my disappointment and demote its importance: My own country, Canada, delivered a very misleading and empty speech with a minimum of effort, but that’s to be expected now, sadly. I’ve got a thorough dissection of the text if anyone is interested. )

So, to sum up (sorry, that wasn’t actually brief at all! J), the agreement reached in Bali has left us an awful lot of work for the next two years. The UN and its agencies are very keen to support this in every way that they can but, to paraphrase Yvo DeBoer, it’s up to countries now. Or, as the EU put it, “the UN is the sum of its member states and it is up to us to determine the size of this sum.”

So, let’s get out there and make sure our countries deliver!!

February 15, 2008 | 7:19 PM Comments  {num} comments



cydnairobi   cydnairobi P.J. Partington's TIGblog
P.J. Partington's profile

first update from the UN (and welcome!)

Hi everyone,

I am writing from the out-moded 2nd floor lobby of the UN Headquarters in New York. Two of us are here as official 'observers' of the General Assembly's two-day debate on Climate Change and the UN.

So far, unfortunately, observing is all we've been able to do. It's been incredibly frustrating through the morning session as we watched a discussion about the importance of "partnerships" and of engaging different levels of governments, stakeholders and individual citizens. After opening speeches by Ban Ki-Moon (Sec-General of the UN) and Michael Bloomberg (Mayor of New York), statements by six panelists, and comments from over 20 delegations and invited audience-members, not ONCE have the words "youth" or "children" been mentioned.

I couldn't count how many times it was stressed by these eminent personalities how important it was to mobilise citizens or forge partnerships with business and civil society; it was practically every second word. But in this "open and frank" discussion, no-one thought to mention what even Ban Ki-Moon has called the most important stakeholder group in the climate change debate: youth and children.

Not once were we asked for our views or allowed to request the microphone. Yet we represent 40% of the world's population and stand to lose (or gain) absolutely everything from our response to climate change. We have the most energy and idealism of any generation in history, but we are being completely sidelined.

So from the 2nd-floor lobby (we weren't invited to the lunch), I am sad to report that despite all the promising signs and kind words in Bali, they still don't get it.

I hope I have better news this afternoon.

February 11, 2008 | 3:07 PM Comments  {num} comments



« previous 5


Owner
This Group TIGBlog is owned by: P.J. Partington.

Membership
PEACE-SEEKER
Adam Brandt
Adam MacIsaac
Adewole Taiwo
Afric Forum
Aiden Abram
Allison
Amb. INALEGWU FRANK UJI
Apeikumo Bubagha
aspen
Bhuwan
Camila Almeida
ចន្រ្ទពង្ស - Chandrapong
Man of the Green Meadow
দেবশ্রীDebashree
NESTA
Elizabeth Fraser
Ernesto B. Rojo Jr.
OWERO
Ieno Vanso
ilyes
It's Getting Hot In Here
Jade Johnston
Vermonster
jean celeste paredes
Jenny
Jess Wishart
Jonathan-Frank
Kathleen Morris
Kimia
YtseJammer
lupe
marie celimene valcourt
Mark Hendrics Jr.
Melinda
Michael Furdyk
Vindicator
Nigel Allan
Nkya George
NNAEMEGO, NKIRUKA
Ogaga Onowighose
oluseun onigbinde
P.J. Partington
Pablo Astudillo
Pauline
PY
R Kahendi
Rhiya Trivedi
Richard Graves
Rishi Aggarwal
Robert Amoafo
Samuel
Sangolade Oyekola
Satya
Suzanna Archibald
Tetteh Kofi Hadjor
Vicente Garcia-Delgado
Wangchuk Chungyalpa
Yassir El Ouarzadi

You must be logged in to join this group TIGblog.

Latest Posts
Cambio Climático y...
Global Warming
Diabolical climate change
Green Earth: Stop your...
Climate and Capitalism

Monthly Archive
February 2008
March 2008
April 2008
May 2008
August 2008
September 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
July 2009
December 2009
March 2011
March 2012
November 2012
December 2012
January 2013
February 2013
March 2013
April 2013
May 2013
June 2013
July 2013
August 2013
September 2013
October 2013
November 2013
February 2014

Change Language



800827 views
Important Disclaimer