TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
Canadian Elections 2008
A place to discuss the up-coming Canadian elections!



DeepEndZen   DeepEndZen Nick Yeo's TIGblog
Nick Yeo's profile

Debat en francais...
About this event: Canadian Federal Elections 2008
Related to country: Canada


Caught the last half hour of the leaders debate en francais...since my french comprehension isn't good enough for me to talk about what the party leaders said, I'll instead focus on what I noticed...

* in terms of their ability to speak french, obviously Dion and Duceppe (being Quebecois) were most comfortable. I was surprised with Harper's ability - although he spoke slowly and deliberately, he didn't seem to feel too out of his element. Layton probably needs to get rid of his anglo-accent - but his delivery was decent. May definitely needs more work, but it was good to hear all of the candidates speaking somewhat fluently. I think one of the leaders slipped into some English, and was quickly reprimanded by the moderator!

* maybe because the setting was in a studio, around a table, with darker tones on the walls and carpet, but this debate felt very much like a conversation - a civil and "polite" discussion between 5 adults on the issues that matter to canadians. much unlike the last election debate, where standing at the podium, you would often hear shouting, posturing and accusations flung across the stage. Most of all I was impressed by Harper (again another surprise for me!) - he almost spoke sotto voce - with a hushed voice. Maybe he intentionally did that to soften his image, to make it seem like he was never on the defensive, that he was firm in his decisions and leadership. Or maybe he just is a soft speaker?

overall, without knowing the actual content of the discussions (i know that they talked about the budget cuts for the arts and canada's role in afghanistan), I can't really assess how well the leaders did on the issues. but I read an interesting article about how debates merely reinforce pre-existing ideas and notions voters have about a particular candidate.

how will tomorrow's english debates fare?

October 1, 2008 | 10:01 PM Comments  2 comments

You must be logged in to add tags.


Comments

minime-kg Kimia
October 5, 2008 | 5:59 PM
harper, calm and collected...so what
thanks for sharing your thoughts nick. I decided to hold off for the english debates which i've been going through now... i have to say that Harper cool and calm composure is probably helping his image...but i don't think he's had very strong arguments in the face of the opposition...He is firm on his decisions but isn't willing to address any shortcomings in his plan, or lack thereof?
DeepEndZen Nick Yeo
October 6, 2008 | 10:47 AM
that's his plan
While no specifics of the tory platform have been revealed - although I understand that this week - the last week of the campaign - we'll see something that represents promises and policies from their camp, the Tory strategy has been to emphasize leadership and decision making as the primary asset.

It's an intriguing tactic - on the one hand, it does create an image of a leader who is (and would be) in control in the face of economic turmoil, international scuffles and other pressures that a PM would face, and when you compare that to the scrapiness of Layton and the ho-hum attitude of Dion, there would be many folks in this country who would vote for Harper.

Still, pooh-poohing other platforms and plans without offering any concrete evidence that you have something better - other than the tortoise approach of slow and steady as she goes... won't engender any new votes from those voters who want to know what the Tories will do for canada's future.

Owner
This Group TIGBlog is owned by: Kirsten Jordan.

Membership
You must be logged in to join this group TIGblog.

Latest Posts
58 percent!!?!?!?!?!
He's Back .... to...
The day after...
Canada Fail
Voting Day

Monthly Archive
September 2008
October 2008

Change Language



15597 views
Important Disclaimer